As usual, comments in blue, article in black... and no mincing of words (That's iNTj for you....)


Creative Types Have a Self-Critical Eye

A career in art may mean bad body image. People who suffer from body dysmorphic disorder, an obsession with imperfections in appearance, are more likely to have an education or occupation in art and design.

By: Rose Palazzolo

Ballet dancers and models are notorious for obsessing about their bodies.

There's a direct correlation between being "fat" and being a Ballet dancer. Its no different to an accountant obsessing obout factual accuracy of numbers.

But what about art historians, fashion designers and architects?
A study of people who suffer from body dysmorphic disorder (BDD), an obsession with imagined or slight imperfections in appearance, suggests they are more likely to have an education or occupation in art and design.

Doctors obsess about diseases they may have. All occupations have their hazzards. If you critically appraise the looks and style of a building then you are likely to be the same with people and yourself.

A group of researchers in London studied 100 people with the image disorder and compared them with groups of people with depression, obsessive-compulsive disorder and posttraumatic stress disorder. Artists, designers and people who have been to art school were five times more likely to suffer from BDD, according to the study, published in the American Journal of Psychiatry.
"An occupation or education in art may be a risk factor for BDD," says lead author David Veale, M.D., psychiatrist and senior lecturer at the University of London. "But we don't know whether it is a cause or an effect."
One theory is that those interested in art are more aesthetically minded, which may carry over to a more obsessive evaluation of their own body. Another possibility is that an education or practice in art or design fosters a more critical eye.

This is where it gets more tricky, people who are not as academically inclinded can by deficit fall into taking creative studies. People who have all sorts of emotional problems (and any other problems) that precludes them from concentrating (adequately) will find respite in creative fields. Furthermore, people with problems are likely to gravitate to areas where the interaction and assocation with others is higher... that is not in process type studies.

"The findings don't surprise me," says Roberto Olivardio, Ph.D., a psychology professor at Harvard Medical School. "I think that people who are artistically inclined might be more visually sensitive."

Thats the occupational element, the emotional element (nature rather than the nurture) leads them to expressive people orientated areas.

The idea for the study was sparked when Veale noted that many of his patients with BDD seemed to be preoccupied with art or design. They were either educated or employed in fine art, art history, graphics, clothing or textile design.

There's plenty of people with this in other occupations, it may well just be that artistic types find it socially acceptable to ask a psychologist about their problems.

"To better understand BDD, we need large epidemiological studies to figure out whether the prevalence of BDD is higher in particular cultures, countries, socioeconomic groups and occupations," adds Katharine Phillips, M.D., an associate professor at Brown Medical School.

How about simply assessing people most likely to obsess about such factors, people who read entertainment and lifestyle magazines, people who are "group" orientated.